EMAIL COMMENTS RECEIVED FROM OUR READERS 
  TALK BACK

 


 
 
Ray:
I just surfed in to your site and was really taken with your views on "tradition". I am a banjo player who likes all banjo music, traditional and not so. I love to play but must admit I am not a "play it like Earl" picker. Even he, was a renegade of sorts to the 5 string pickers before him. He is so freekin' good that to try to imitate him I believe does him an injustice of some sort. Yet I believe most staunch traditionalists think he and Lester were the epitome of traditional bluegrass. I don't think from reading your editorial that your view of traditionalism is that narrow? Is it? I ask only because I just hate it when I hear someone say "pick it like Earl".
 
I love good bluegrass music but I also have to admit that it's hard for me to listen to players of lesser ability for any length of time. (The operative here is "listen".) Bluegrass to me is lively and full of inspiration, heartache and everything else life brings with it. Its simplicity is hard for some musicians to capture and still maintain that something that comes through as listenable. Does that make sense to you? I think you are right on about keeping with tradition and I aspire to do just that. It's just that I don't feel I have the talent to make the traditional sound traditional. I am a good player and I know it but I don't want you to think I'm being self aggrandizing with this self assessment. It's just that I think playing traditional bluegrass is beyond my ability and therefore I choose to play what I have been told by my audiences is good to listen to.
 
So, how can I help to promote traditional bluegrass music? I buy what traditional music I can afford and play some traditional songs during my shows but freely admit that I make more money and gain more audience by playing more progressive genres. I recently was jamming with Frank Wakefield and we were discussing this very subject. He wasn't quite so staunchly opposed to the new wave bluegrassers of today as were some of his band mates. They too didn't care much for bands like Nickle Creek yet they admired the Del McCoury band. You even mention Del and Rhonda as to be aspirations for up and comers. Have you ever tried to play along to their recordings? They are progressive to the nth. That's why they are where they are at the top of the bluegrass feeding chain. To me Nickle Creek and their ilk have taken traditional bluegrass instrumentation to the masses especially the younger generation. That being said, I think it is because of folks like them that I'm seeing younger faces in my audiences. (or maybe it's just me that's getting older at 54)  At any rate, I think you and I are in agreement that the newbies are contributing to bluegrass music by bringing a new generation into the fold. Hopefully, I hope that more and more people take up playing bluegrass music and the traditional is a good starting point. It's as you said,  it's very approachable to the beginning player but oh so hard to master. Maybe it's as I've heard said about playing the blues, "if you haven't lived it, you can't play the blues". Traditional bluegrass is a genre that a musician must live to be played with any sense of tradition. I don't know how to do that. Can you help me?
 
Thanks for taking the time to read this. I think you have put forth some great thoughts but I'm not fully understanding of how best to keep it traditional.  
 
Dave in Cleveland
 
 
Ray, Sharon and the Bluegrass Community    
      I would like to start off by saying you have produced an excellent web page!  I enjoy spending my free time browsing through all of the helpfull information you have available.  I am 25 years old, in the military and I am currently learning to play the banjo......I LOVE IT TO DEATH.......  The only complaint I have is there is alot of negative talk about the younger people interested in bluegrass. How can the traditional bluegrass community keep these young kids focused and teach them the roots if we are constantly critising other music they might listen too.  As I am writing this I am listening to Flat & Scrugs 1942-52 album but by tomorrow morning on my way to work I might be listening "Rock or Crap" I mean rap.  These younger folks should not be judged in how society has evolved the youth as we know it today.  We come from the land of the free that gives us the right to have all varietys of music to listen to and enjoy.  Some have chosen other variations not knowing what else there is to offer.  Fortunatly I have an excellent banjo instructor who is teaching how to play the roots way and not this new grass millenium influenced music.  Now dont get me wrong "to each his own"........  I have an ear for all varieties of music probly because of my upbringing but that does not make me any less worthy to indulge in the beautiful sweet music of bluegrass.  I can still listen, play and respect bluegrass while listening to other variations of music on the side.  I hope nobody takes offense to this suggestion but just embrace the youger generation opening their eyes to bluegrass.  Bluegrass means more than music to me it is about respect, god, tradition and good ole' sweet country music.  Lets show them what its all about!  Educate them and they will come, critise them and they will run away!!!!  Lets keep this tradition going!  God Bless!
 
                                                                     Brandon "Plucky" Herrington
                                                                     Oklahoma City, OK

 
 
Hey it would be great if everyone would join The Del Mccoury Band Message board or bulletin board. Things havnt been to hype on it lately. Well come on over to the site at www.delmccouryband.com! I will keep everyone posted on Del Mccoury news on the site.
 
          Mike
 
 
Hey I would like to introduce myself to all the bluegrass road users. My name is Mike and I live in Mathews County VA in the beatiful country. I am in a gospel bluegrass band and I play the mandolin. I am a huge bluegrass fan and will always be. I love music and I always have.  By the way good article Ray I enjoyed reading it.  Yes I have asked some of those questions before!   Anyway glad to be here and What a great site!
 
Mike

 
 
Hello; I haven't stayed up long enough lately to catch either one of you guys in the chat room, but I wanted to tell Sharon that I found the "Green Tomato Pie" recipe on the website. I tried it and it was a big hit!!  My Dad said that it reminded him of a mild raisin pie.
       We enjoyed the show up at the Sally Mountain Park. We didn't stick around after, though because I had a sunburn that was bothering me, and we had a bit of a drive back......
 
                                                                   Take Care; Patsy
 
 
Hey Ray,
 
     Barry C.  here. Just read your fine article on Bluegrass Road (Mission Statement). I could smell the wind changing with O' Brother Where Art Thou. It started smelling like money and Nashville got a whiff it seems. I've always wanted bluegrass to get more notoriety but like you, not at the expense of tradition. 
     Now that IBMA is moving to Nashville (suit country) I guess we will see where the loyalty lies.
     I also agree about the young people. They are coming out of their rock and crap, ooops, I mean rap and have no inkling of the tradition of bluegrass. I have an 11 year old nephew who is taking an interest in banjo and I'm thankful for that. But he is also a fan of rap. I will teach him all I can in the history and tradition of bluegrass music. I've been pickin for thirty years and was raised on it. 
     I will do all I can on my end to keep the tradition alive but I have no monetary way of doing that. Word of mouth is all I can do.
     Well, I've rambled enough. I really like this site by the way. Keep up the good work.  

 

 
  EDITORIAL COMMENT:

Ray,
You hit the nail on the head, Been bluegrassin ever week since last winter,
Go to a festival, maybe you will see one or two band's that is doing it
right. I am not saying these are not great  pickers, they are. but they have
to play there own music, or what they have wrote themselves.  There are not
many Larry Cordel's out there.   I understand, they make their living on
cd's, but all the cd's I have ever bought only had one or two good tracts,
and the rest were fillers. Another thing, this clowning around has gone to
extreme, we have a fine band here in southern Ohio, I will even name the
city (********,******).There acts have gotten out of control. As Ray Davis says,
"It's Plum Pitiful". Just had to get this off my chest, By the way will be
seeing this band in question next week, they are a fine group of musicians.
I hope they play "Uncle Penn" Thanks.


 
  Hi Ray

I see you continue to add good features to your website.  And you continue your focus on  Bluegrass music and Bluegrass only. 

Does that mean that you or I only like Bluegrass to the exclusion of all other music?  I think that the answer is "Of course, not!"

I like most of the acoustic string band styles that have arisen in our country during the last  two or three centuries.  I regularly play with a group  of "Old Time" country musicians who play the fiddle tunes that were popular in the Ohio Valley and Appalachians during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.  That music is Bluegrass music's crusty old grandfather.  Other regional styles of string music are to be found in our country.  Like the New England and Maritime Province  styles of fiddle music that were around in Maine when my Mother was a girl there.  Or Western music, both traditional Cowboy music and Western Swing. 
I also like the string band Jazz of the sort played by Eddie Lang and Joe Venuti, Eddie South or Stuff Smith (and their french cousins "The Hot Club of Paris").  There's 19th century Minstrel banjo which was the original popular banjo music.  Plus Celtic string band music which is the other ancient ancestor of all string band music played today.

But should the Bluegrass Road site cover these styles also?  I don't think so.  I think you should focus on just the Bluegrass style, and let someone else do an "Old Time" or "Western" or "Celtic" website.  But do include links to those sites if you come across good ones!

Joe Richman


 
 
Hey Ray,
 
 This is Jimmy Campbell. How are you guys? Hope all is well. Anyway, I really enjoy your new website. It has awesome links and is full of information. Good Job Ray. I didn't know you had it in ya. Ha. Ha.
 I checked out Bass St. awhile back and found a Peavey 520  with very little use on E-bay for $125.00 Then I made the holder at work. (Luckily I have access to a welder.) I got a chance to try it out Friday night when I filled in on mandolin with the Loose Gravel Boys. I let their bass player try it and it sounded awesome. The clarity of all the bass notes were very clear and responsive. I couldn't believe how well it sounded.
 You're a genius!
 
Thanks,
 
Jimmy Campbell  Edwardsville, Ks.               ---  Southern Reign Band

Ray  -  I've been called lots of things, genius was never one of em....    hehehe   

 

 
 
Bull
  Just finished reading your editorial and we both say hooray !!!! Yer doing a good job of standing up but wonder if it will count ?? Sure wish I was as eloquent as you to express my opinion. The most I can say is that they can NEVER kill original Bluegrass. It's part of our heritage. Like most old fogies I don't think this new fangled stuff will work and it certainly won't sound like what I grew up with.  Keep up the great work!!
 
Rick & LaDonna
 

 

 
  Did you hear who won the SPBGMA bluegrass band competition this year?  It was a band called King Wilkie and they are signed with REBEL records.   If I were in the competition I’d be a little upset about that.  It’s pretty ridiculous when they let professionals enter and win the contest.   When our band went, we were in with 5 or 6 bands that were professionals and a couple were signed with Hay Holler and Pinecastle.   I took my wife and daughter, but they required us to be present all the time, so we didn’t get to do any site seeing.  We never made the third cut, took the top 10 band and we were 11th.

BM

 
 
Yea Ray!!
 
I agree.
 
I'm in a jam with some others, (they pick a lot better than I do), BUT, they'll throw in a cowboy or a folkish tune or two, and it drives me nuts.
 
If I wanted to play country, or folk, I'd search it out and pick with those kind of players....but I don't.   I got to have my BLUEGRASS...Flat- out bluegrass.  Nothin else. 
 
Good job on the article.
 
jm

Sincerely,
John Melito

 

 
 


Ray & Sharon...
What a great website.  I have enjoyed it tremendously.  We have not seen you since the showcase at Springdale.  As you recall, we are a new band and the showcase was our first performance for the public.  We did quite well.  As a result we have the following bookings: 
Feb. 28 at Spring in Joplin, MO....
March 13 Arcola Christian Church, Arcola, MO.....
a guest shot May 15 at Ponderosa Bluegrass, Lynchburg,Mo....

July 8,9 10 Adona , Ark.......
Sept 30, Oct 1, Clinton, MO.
The band consists of:  Billy Barber - banjo, lead & tenor....Jason Jordan - mandolin, lead & harmony.....Chad Graves - dobro, lead & harmony.....Cliff Newsom - guitar, lead...Pam Newsom - bass, lead & harmony.....I have enclosed a picture of the band.  
I enjoyed your article about the bass mic's.  That has been a true concern of mine....you tune and tune and then BOOM....your out.  I never did like that 'roll the mic in foam' technique.
Keep up the good work..........I'll keep reading...
......................Pam Newsom
                           "Just In Tyme" Bluegrass

 
 
Hi, Ray and Sharon,
 
Just checking out your web site.  Congratulations!  I like the idea of thinking of it as a bluegrass "magazine".    Haven't hit all the parts of it yet, but so far, I have checked out the recipes (can we submit some to you?) and the "links" and am looking forward to information that you will be giving in the computer tips section.  And the humor part about a clean house more likely to happen when the computer is broken is so TRUE!   I will be checking back to see what's new. And "thanks" for having our Festival listed.
 
Neva
 
  Hi Ray.   I dug your editorial on your webpage about bluegrass.   You are exactly right.  The progressives,  while they have every right to play whatever they want,  are taking "bluegrass"  to some strange places. Actually they are leaving it behind.  I get frustrated because I listen to the TV station I have on my satellite that is supposed to be bluegrass and it's half banjoless.  I'm a banjo picker and I'm shameless about it.  But let me tell you what,  If you listen to it and it's medium or up tempo and it hasn't got a banjo in it,  it's just not bluegrass!  Period.  End of argument.   That's how it is.  Also,  if you listen to it and four or five songs go by that have non traditional instrumentation it ain't bluegrass. That's fine,  if you don't want to play bluegrass play something else, but don't call it bluegrass and don't clutter the airwaves with it.  It's bait and switch.  I get so angry about it.  Folks come up to me and they tell me they like bluegrass,  you know like the *****  *********  I tell 'em that that ain't bluegrass any more than it's polka and they just look at me like I'm nuts.   I play bluegrass and so does our band.  We know what it is.  You don't have to play the same old tunes over and over to be a traditional band. You can even play brand new music as long as it's of the right form.   Sorry for the rant but that's how I feel.  Hope to  see you soon. 

RM of Missouri
 


 

 
 
Ray:
 
I will try to keep you up to date on any new things going on with the Village Singers.
 
BTW really liked the site.
 
Warren Goad
The Village Singers
www.villagesingers.com
 

 
 
  Sharon,

Just checking out your new website and it is excellent.  Very
attractive, informative and easy to use.

Have a great New Year,

Wayne Bledsoe - Bluegrass Now Magazine     www.bluegrassnow.com

 

 
 

Murray Pritchard,   Ontario, Canada